Wednesday, July 31, 2019
John Sayles | Sunshine State
nature on a leash
by Douglas Messerli
John Sayles (writer and director) Sunshine State / 2002
If there were ever a question of independent director John Sayles’ ability to gain a wider popular following, certainly his 2002 comedy-drama Sunshine State should push away all doubt. While Sayles’ film, in its focus on several different families in the small Florida town of Delrona Beach and environs, is rather convoluted, but its characters (all excellent actors) draw you into a world that is gradually being wiped away by developers, while whose leftover denizens are fighting the impossible battle of maintaining a status quo.
The film begins with a group of wealthy retiree golfers, led by comedian Alan King, who, like a Greek chorus, cynically tell of the changes happening to the area (filmed mostly on Amelia Island, Florida), luring in just their kind. As King or another of his group describes it, the developers are putting “nature on a leash,” taming the wild growth and animal life of this outlier paradise, into a place where the well-to-do can finally feel comfortable. It is a familiar theme in contemporary life: big business against small. Japanese director Kurosawa could have made a different version of this film.
Desiree, as a young girl, we discover, was one of the high-school football player (now Heisman Trophy winner) Lee "Flash" Phillips’ (Tom Wright) lovers, who, when she got pregnant, was sent away by her mother to Georgia to have the baby which died in birth. The resentment and fury of that expulsion is written on her face, even as she attempts to make amends to her mother for her long refusal to return. Reggie, a gentle being, gains the approval of the cultural fossil of well-meaning Eunice; yet we recognize the mother as an incredibly loving woman who simply could not face the community disavowal or their notions about how blacks behaved. To engage her new-charge in something creative, she demands a wooden coffin be built—a bit like Addie in William Faulkner’s As I Lay Dying; yet, although to her daughter she may appear as a kind vulture, she is not preying on her child as much as the society has preyed on her.
Desiree soon re-encounters her youthful lover, discovering that he is now working, on the side, for the business interests who intend to gentrify the island. Eunice is not interested in selling her house.
Marly might have been saved a bit from her circumstances if it weren’t that her mother (the always amazing Jane Alexander) weren’t so self-involved (others might describe her as community-centered), who runs a local non-profit theater in which she stars in roles such as Electra and other major female heroines.
At least Desiree has supposedly escaped, but Marly has no route out, working herself to death as a bartender/manager who has so many desires to be fulfilled that she might as well be in that cage of water, performing as a mermaid, without a breath of air.
In the end, the past goes deeper and darker, as the tractors, attempting to dig up the “wild” land of the island, suddenly uncover sculls, those of the most ancient of the areas’ citizens, original American Indians, whose sudden appearance turn the entire area into a space of national significance. Golfers beware! You have no right to play through this hallowed ground.
Finally, it seems a little bit simplistic to simply have the issue resolved by history itself. Yet that has been the subject of the entire film. History, the past, memories, investment in the culture are the subjects of this work. The strong women, all the film’s characters, have been fighting all their life to make a meaning in a world apart from the mainland, which attempted to attract visitors with ditties such as the Irving Berlin song which closes this movie:
Everybody sings of the sunny South
That's the song that clings to the singer's mouth
They ragtime it and boost the climate
Way up to the sky
Never cared a lot for the Swanee shore
There's another spot that I'm rooting for
I've been there and I must declare
It can't be praised too high
If I had my way, I'd always stay
In Florida among the palms
With its peaceful air of "I don't care"
And lazy atmosphere that calms
My one favorite haunt
Is a palm tree, and all I want
Is someone just to rest in my arms
I'd love to live among the bamboo huts, the cocoanuts
There's something in the climate that charms
Heaven's corridor is sunny Florida
Home of the shelt'ring palms
Los Angeles, July 31, 2019
Reprinted from World Film Review (July 2019)